11/1
2005
LAW
Pap-e, 1
Time: 3 }fours I llvfa:nmum lHarhs aDO

INSTRUCTIONS
Each quc8tion i8 pnnted both rn English and In Kannada.
Answers must be [nritten in the medium specifIed (English or Kannuda) [II the Adnllssioll TiChet issued to which mU8t he stated clearly on the of the answer book in the space prounled for this purpose. No credit will be given for the IIllS/VcrS UJrI:U{'fl Ul medium other than that ::;pecified in the Admission Trc/?1!t. III case douht in the Kannada text, jJ!casc refer to English text.
This paper has {our parts:
A 20 marks
B 100 marks
C 90 marks
D 90 marks

Marks allotted to each question arc mdicated in each part.
Ail questions in Part it, Part B and Part C are compulsory. /1.llswer any three questions in Part D.
. 8-9 0t3dc;?
11/1 PART A
Answer each question in about 50 words. Each question carries marhs.
1. Explain the 'Doctrine of Pleasure' under the Indian Constitution.
State the essential features of a Federal Constitution.
Who are the subjects of International law
Elucidate the territorial jurisdiction of a State.

131 11/1

;ztc:1JJUJ 50 i:fcir/9ri en)1BA 0dJ
5
1. (wi AJcZJt;SdFJeJ (Doctrine of Pleasure)

iJco'o:.or1:J

[Turn over
11
PART B
Answer each qllet-.'lwn U1 about 100 words. Each question carnes 10 marhs.
1.
Explain the definition of for the purposes of fundamental rights.

2.
State briefly the facets of the principles of natural justice.

3.
Explain the doctrine of 'Classification'. State its influence and impact on Art. 14 of the Constitution.

4.
Discuss the diffE.'fcnt modes of the amendment of the Indian Constitution.

5.
Distinguish betv,'een 'Fundamental Rights' and 'Directive Principles of State Policy.'

6.
What is piracy jure genh'um How is it dealt with by States?

7.
Explain the theories regarding the relation between International Law and Municipal Law.

8.
\That are the different types of state recognition? Vhat is the legal effect of recognihon 7

9.
What is meant by 'Extradition' Mention the conditions required to be satisfied for it.

10.
Explain the powers and functions of the Security Council, with referenc(' to maintenance of international peace and seuurity.



m


o b rz

a " 136J tJ "

L
x i2 :DtJ "Ie
a q c· 13
17­
o
iJ b

18 lJ tJ
"
b ·t3 p.r f1 II n lJ
t;l

a t
Ii

13 "Ii:
13 13 t

13
til o
"lP"



"J b i2 "18 lJ
18 12""

F o

12
mer
b b ]2iii o0

11 F
b C oJ J"tJ
o 1:p G c-· "C 6J

01 o f'lF a " n
" In " 13 o t..
C0
" f"lJ

c·
F
o;"l
o

p 0"3 c·b " fJ
c " f2
"t;l

tl rtcD 6-3 o ."
11'jo "b;J

a "tTl" 1P i)tjB lJ 12
o
a 13 " " lJ. 12
t n C3 lJ c
l1)}.1 lJ n
o re. B'.J "

rJ lJ n s 2 otil rti

;je to L
b
lJ[Jto fJ. " ­W
" ""r
J;j "J 1:3 lJ D
j" y-» .......

rJ
(ftJ t.f1 j.Z " 12 " 0" ..
fJ oil
1 jpgH .":s..., v 23
" c" 63 v b lP 0 Y.l' b Ele 13 o
v c'00 t· btl tl b G
b If Pi
11 c,l ?pJ 6 G

h1 rJ01 C" r.i tt-D b 3 §
1111 161
PART C nx15=90
Answer earh question UI-ahout 150 words. Each question carnes
15 marks.

1.
"The power to make laws and the powers to levy taxes are separately enumerated in the Indian Constitution." -Elucidate.

(bl In a state, the entire road transport was run by the state, as it
was managed departmentally. But, later, under a law passed by the
State Legislature, a State Road Transport Corporation was brought
mto existence. The new corporation is asked to pay income tax. The
state claims immunity under Art. 289 of the Constitution. Decide,
giving reasons.


2.
la) Discuss the scope and content of ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Art. 131 of the Constitution.

Ibl The State of Karnataka entered into a contract with the Union of
India to supply sandalwood products of a certain quality for a fixed
price. The contract complied with Art. 299 of the Constitution of
India. There was anticipatory breach of the contract on the part of
the Union of India. The Government of Karnataka filed a suit
under Art. 131 of the Constitution, claiming for an order of specific
performance. Decide, giving points of arguments for both parties.


3.
(al Discuss the fundamental rights available to a detenu. Ibl Mr. A was detained under the National Security Act on the solitary 6'TOund that "he was a member of X political party". On what

6'TOunds would you challenge the detention Mention the fora before which you will take up the matter.

4.
Discuss passing of rights and obligations upon external changes of sovereignty over territory.


The British ship 'Columbus' collided with the Indian ship
'Gameland' on the High Seas, due to the negligence of an officer on
board 'Columbus'. As a result, 'Gameland' sank and 20 Indians
died. The Indian Government wants to claim compensation. Advise
on the issue of jurisdiction.

I
c ill

" <co x U !J. 13 10 0 IJ 12 rJ C ....... ". illD 60[ b W 1b) C3 0 m"J v V. 1J" re . PJ G n "Y2. 0 12 fJ" "fJ "" rJ b I go.g"l:).-:lJ G 8 jj fl c.C 13 eCJ" 1<.. 131J n1f F f0 b 12" .g F 13 12 " 12":13 ..... it'G rJ 1I:J -50 1Z I" " G "18 13 n" f" Ie (j. b B n • l" [tl rt 1»1 C., 6J b i3 3 jj G b l:l D 1 l:3 ;If n 0 rG fl l:l 1;3 G H -1P 12 .eS n v 2 c B G 16 .. Cl " " b 0 Lu c 0 N­8 lP-J .-J J:l lP t-etl ("I"l"3!c n D b B DoH0·( rc "1:3 w c3 n cG lP 0 0 f;j fJ rc n lJ " G IBbLuQ 13 Lv ij> IJ 13 lJ "Db r" liJ-J v 12 a ">rJ" n v Ono·' on n t• fJ n 13, lJ rJ b n b .-J 0 l3 G 0 nJ it ..... Do .g v la J 0 b 0 [3. n " u ".3 rIc") cS­:J "X B ty"m lJ (J­"lJ . 13 12 lP tJ 0 1:3 fi :lBI"l'bb5G " b olo 6" tZ IP IP u 0 H ltl w F o ill 12" " " o tJ 1J 13 OJ o G· o iP v IJfJ g g gf3. " 13 iPltl B 0 2 he} o h • GO 0 121.1 13 a c-. F ... 0 g v " 13 0 ... fJ 13 H l:l .g " b 131 1J11 X .golf f2 2 it j.J 15'3 0" o "1» f2 tJ'J­«d;JlJ lO n 8 " o b " '18G· l. IlJ " " i>3 cJ lC 0 n b 0 13lJ lJa rJ qr til 0 13 1Z 8"12 b tJ;:J­l3 18,10 i.j :Dl3Gb-H­13 r.l"l a r S Ss H jj 0r) C """ "" "i 8 fJ iJ t 13 b 6Jl13 11) G1J v {Oco""1!l D IJ 13 " lirZ anbb131» v -Qj ""J""l3 U 1Y 0 b G 6 b 0D IJ "!ti 'Iil" U • U "to v 12 c o t:c


.."



181
Explain the rights and duties of States 1,.vith regard to aliens.
Albert, a British national, along with a hundred men madp
preparations to commit piracy on the high seas. But, the attempt
failed due to a U.S. ""'arship's entry into that area. The pirate ship
landed on Indian soil. Albert and his men are arrested and tried in
Indian courts. Albart contends that Indian courts have no
jurisdiction as they have not commlttl'd any wrong. Advise the
Indian Government.
6. Enumerate and explain the different methods of peaceful settlement
of international disputes.
2. (bl 1Ir. Ratel, States of a sailor was surrendered by Great Britain to the Untled America, upon a charge of murder of Frederick. The
American court tried and convicted Ratel for a minor charge of
Ib inflicting cruel and unusual punishment on Frederick. Examine the
validity of the extradition, trial and conviction.

4. (bl

ill


o
ICC n
Ii]


g "D n 03 6j) 1-J
v 0
V L" Ol?

rJbl

nr" 0 13
o r{.Jb J
13 <lj rJ 0
iJa
tJ "J lJ l;u

CotJ
0
I" 1302,?

" b 3 I" ey1
n. 13
lJ J:l v
g 0
12 rJ
n
" 0 <Jf H 0 "lJ 13
" C3 0 QJ 13

v
13 . 13
jll c
o . r3
" ;Jt B
fJ
".!3 0
11 -rJ '1p"P f2 "l i'tfl P

rc fi1
C u.J
II'j o." fJ i.J o· n
o 12
D o
lJ· b B
m 60) tJ
mo b hi
b V
U Cc"tJ "0H
tl 8 it 0 o J 1P

f2" '"Tel H l-t l1{l

13" . t1 yy oJ r6
9 • P 12 13­
"
tl 1i..l. . . a o .. 0
n 13 D
o· "j
o 1"3 H'rz 1i b fJ" "Ill Ih 1)3
G 0 p .2
o tZ 1lJ't FD II! "2 tJ 13­
F
;313 n iJ."" rc F
CJ H:l
C
It> 15.
CJ a


. r-Y
o Pd 1,. .R " oJ'lJ20
" n i.J

13 _OJ b 10_ II

'til J5 b lJ) b b
0 G3
13 ¥0G G
ri") 13 U tl-fi)"j
" "
ld II 8. .J


.D

oi

11/1 10)
PART D 3x30=90
Answer any three oj" the !'ol!ou.nng questions, each in ahout 300 /-L'ortIs. Each question carries
L Discuss the scope and content of the freedom of the press in the iJght of judicial pronouncements of the Supreme Court of India.
2.
Explam briefly the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India.

3.
Explam critically the doctrines invoked by the Supreme Court to resolve legislative conflicts between the Union and the States.

4.
Explain the material 'sources' of International Law. In what order are these material 'sources' used for ascertaining the law on a given matter?

5.
Discuss the nature and scope of state responsibility. Vill there be any state responsibility in case of breach of a treaty or breach of contractual obligations?


o
N

­co
"
1:3 c b
.,f" .r 130 f3
iJ J iZ
o
ljeC) o

rJ

oJ o
q b c o o­fJ­
}.YI H c:. o
B e:J
tJ
Ii l3'l rJ B
"" S
"

}to
o;Jf )3 o "if
8
F ­n
IS
p "8 lfl a
lJ iJ
11> tl
r.:
.8rJ 3 l:t
lb
Cl

b
bff t,·
l: tJ "18 f ti
h1 iCo
. b lo., 10 d!f iC)
a "G 0
FJ
" 0
C C i G TJ. IJ" "tl 11>
C) f.c R
. 18 " 1'5» d on
B 4J"k
Ii 10
" t I")b
F2 rt
t3 h n
0 0
:r.
1:3" l'ln
Q If) .J H 13
F

" .. f" 13 jJ fJ.
v oJ o
r·) h IJf
ro 12 (.l 2
.;),..... c t2 tr 62 ltJ 13
r'oJ
q Q b· "Il;
G
C
l.ib rI l:512 a
tJ
o
i.J fjt2
v


q,j Qf 13-"
d " h 2
't.P
tp F Wli 13
F
iJ "pb 11>1 tJ 13
1:3 h
ah IJ
b,. »)0 b(0 r
PJ b -·tilN ri H llJ 15
to C
..
" l.r' P L



111/2 I
2005
LAW
Paper 2
Time: 3 flours J Maximum Marks: 300

INSTRUCTIONS
Each quesfwn is printed both in English and in Kannada.
Answers must be luritten In the medi1-lm specified (English or Kannada) in the Admission Ticket iss4ed to you, which must be stated clearly on the cover of the U'lswer book tn the space provided for this purpose. No credit will be given for the ans/,oers written in a medium other than that specified in the­Admission Tichet. In case of any dOUbt in the Kannada text, please refer to English text.
This paper has four parts:
A 20 marks
B 100 marks
C 90 marks
D 90 marks

Marks allotted to each question are indicated in each part.
All questions in Part Part Band Parl C are compulsory. Answer any three questions in Part D.
• Sf cc¥ct Sf if,jOJrJ05) o:illl0;C:0;)fi d
tol "1I" "
11/2 121
PART A
Answer each question in about 50 words. Each question carnes 5 marks.
1. Write a note on mens rea In statutory offences.
Define 'Tortious liability'.
Explain contract. the essentials required for the formation of a valid
Define from a a 'Contract of sale of goods'. 'Hire purchase agreement' In what way is it dif ferent

•

11/2
4x5=20
50 03c!1l'!Prf f:fl!1D,t


c:mCRWw'
[Turn over
11/2 141

PART B lOxlO=ioo
Answer each question in atout 100 words. Each question carnes 10 marks.
1.
Ramu is having his early morning walk on a public road. Kalu, showing a revolver, stops him. Ramu, for fear of his life, hands over his wrist watch, mobile phone and a gold chain to Kalu. Has Kalu committed any offence? Elucidate.

2.
Dr. Bilappa, working in a Government Hospital, performed tubectomy on Smt. Vinita, mother of two daughters of 5 years and years of age. This


was as part of a state-sponsored Family Planning Programme. After a year, Smt. Vinita gave birth to a female child. What relief can be claimed by Smt. Vinita and against whom? Decide.
3.
John lost his cell phone in a park. Jack found it and took it home. He thought of returning it to the owner, when the owner issued an advertisement giving his name, address, etc. But, in the mean time, it was stolen from his house, at night. John wants to claim the cost from Jack. Decide, giving reasons.

4.
Vikas sold goods worth Rs. 5 lakhs to Vilas on credit of 1 month. The goods were sent through a carrier. Before the goods reached the destination, Vilas became insolvent, within a week after the sale. State the remedies available to Vikas. Can the receiver of the debtor-Vilas have any relief?

5.
The Government of Karnataka purchased 20 Maruti Esteem cars for its new Ministers, which were refused by the Ministers. Mr. Govinda, without authority, purchased one of them, for his principal Mr. Kapoor, at the auction sale conducted for the sale of these new cars, on 10.4.2005, subject to approval by his principal. But, on 12.4.2005, the auction sales were cancelled. On 14.4.2005, Mr. Kapoor approved the purchase made by Gavinda. Explain, who has the ownership of the car.


•



N
a
ill

a
II n 16l? 12 n v v In o
a 1" n° if 10 t3 0c
13 rLo
<OJ


x 10 H l3 IJ
a-G 1J II fj 0 f­
.l rl Ii: -.t
n 138-" iti 13 b FJ,
o 61)1 «3 <»Z N 12 r.C n ·Ii iii o b P lC at n 0

B " F rJ lJ n 12
13G 0 HJOl<>VObr>
n
B oj fj B b tl
v 5 fl 5
rJ 0 b 1o Bb 13 II

1»
II w B-e b iii a v"f1 OJ Cl
"D 03
'lI3 Ci y., f rJ 12 00 10"1
{i1 H n 13
10 18 a t3:n rJ 5 b rJ 12 OJ'"13
tl 16 D
12 6J f8 N .H
b ft V1 .1 B .... If)

i.i fJ 13 13 1f, B ill b <Go
Q... 0 b 13 12 13f1 B 13 fJ "lP
16 1Jl 13 18 ra
F 13 fJ II l;l 13 r"
b tl Ci f2
'tS5 IJ 10 13 G3 1-3 N. Hi·t13 WtJ
:12 "0 6J 1tJ
Q:l 13 12"1' a F2 12b btl"
10' v ••
6J il II Ci . fJ f3. " rJ> b
CD 10) IG "l3 a f1 ro:
13 y.? 13 fi 13 8 l;l
eJ'J 'ltl v
tl d R 16 fi
@f.l(jadQf fc. 1tl)<t 113 12 1P 6.0£ 12
v.... 12","D> V G
53
10 °f8 I 6G B n n°
a bel "iiJ 12 )j -e"F a Ii:
t iJ b b fj f2 13. n 10
13 13(1 rB Oil n Yo 13 p
II n a rJ rJ
10 Gl v-. 18 ". "b
.r.l nb 2" b·J itilJ 5 'Jij 13 13 tJ 1;P E rJ" ES 130 n
a 13 1:3 b )p"J b
....... 6 N F f.l -If 0 cJ"

h
12 eJ. F 12 v
G J2 Iii fj
.J noj Ii)
0 b "t2 "" l3 12 12 f3" a
V1 ill 3
.J B • 13 "" dlJ
12 .J 13 . o.;p 0 b "tZb f<.. .. b Db'l3 g iJ rJ r§ E
R f1 M fl
jJ 13 ili
.J;n a lu:r>b
" l;l <GYJ
·,b ei) . 311 16. b f1
r3 . o .1= "lP eJ V1 l;l
"

Wl'1"O 13 0 oJ

a "CoO"
l3
I'll 1o"C1ob"
.
II b D "1 y.,
"J B 1J Lu oii' 13 ..> !J.J0 '0In r., °0 b cD lu J3 u0[ h 0
e­
l"" (.l 0 6. n n .1 f2 l:J

OJ
.j_ P Il L a 1P "





11/2 (6 I

6.
A landlord in a village, at the request of the villagers, allowed a portion of his land to be used as a burial ground. But, he did not allow the Daliths to use it. Does this amount to any offence under the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 Give reasons.

7.
A Food Inspector takes a sample of an article of food being sold by Narayan and sends it to the Public Analyst for analysis. As per the procedure, he ought to do so in the presence of one or more persons and take their signatures. But, he has taken the sample in the presence of a person working in his Department and taken his signature. The food article was adulterated. Narayan is convicted. Narayan challenges his conviction. Decide as per the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act.

8.
Rajan agreed for the marriage of his son, Ranu with Reeta, daughter of Milind. Milind paid Rajan Rs. Two lakhs as dowry, before the wedding. The marriage did not materialise. Mihnd demanded the return of the Rs. two lakhs. Rajan refused. Can Milind sue for recovery, in a court of law? Decide as per the Indian Contract Act and the Dowry Prohibition Act.

9.
Thomas, the employer of Joseph, presents a cheque of Rs. 25,000 to Joseph on the occasion of Joseph's marriage. This is given because Joseph has been very useful to Thomas in his business. Shortly thereafter, Joseph leaves the employment. The cheque is dishonoured by the Bank. Advise as to the liability of Thomas and the rights of Joseph, as per the Negotiable Instruments Act.

10.
Munna, aged years, is admitted to benefits of a partnership firm,


B of which Abraham and Balu are partners. Munna holds himself out as a partner and enters into a contract, on behalf of the firm, to purchase goods worth Rs. One lakh. The firm disowns the contract, saying Munna is a minor and is not the agent of the firm. Decide, with reference to the Indian Partnership Act.
•


N
o

il it 13 W b "lO-p (Oi Q[-£1"1 F iiP 13 ili ili c


o b f­
c5 b lJ Ii!



B Iii 10'J "13 13h -71 F0
D b 12 1"2. "0
iJ'g j fJ "D rp" e v
b il ""
D " 13 0;» OJ b 13 o.,g
TI N
lJ D " ...... D fJ
rJ "tb ilN ,"to
lP·'.
-li 1J lP H f.j 13 wlJ
il "13 0
16 1=J .Q
iij-o
r[l n "
tl .Q
b 12w to 12 ij Iii
0
Q...-a Iii IJB tl 13-h f.j
tl e g 18f).J" Iii
F b
6» 12 c5 n "l lP
D <otJQn e 2 fl'3q
" OJ D
"ttl 2:l 10 "lP f.,j
0" P"l ofl 0
oJ 18 fz b a iti .(J 6<l 18 b o>c fj. f3,0"Q
0
o 12 " "D 6 0
o 10 "<0b fJ 13

rJ 13 10 /.j.J IS) qj ,til
il Pi rG
01 b rJ o!J n 3 13 a .13c 0
v :Db _wn F fJ
b fP 13 tl .
b 'Jlj "
lP tl ill 0 13 12°
rz .J b il b b ili 13 -is h Ba w 0"'EJ th ili
OJ
" b );IF!8l3b b
lof,j:D n rJ i2
tl 13 10'13 fl-a fJ tl o Ub b
1"»1 f2 " lJ
01
f Q£j to
m

B 12 Iii i:J tl !"913 a 13 . 13 If 0
g" Go bG fi)1 TI (Ol "D D b 13 "l D D
1031t;Wfl) 13 0 r.,j W1
bJ iJ
oJ a 12"05F
l<l o!J
Iii 13 c.: OJ OlP'5J
16 0
iJJ 03 Iii t Bl3 EE IH IJ 5 .g oi
F6 0
cO b wtl
0 Iii
OJ
J il il 13 13-5 0 133"" u
Iii 11a .. ga3 . a

0
Blivh:D
qn 1J 120b tl tl l3 F "" nO HO
0" w"O 13 a
1B 13 rz 13 " fJ-N "Ii n iJ 12 :Dtltl
"G tl " 13
rz i:J 1:1 b t2 60). b .,p B S
0
lJ Ji E o b
J., 0 lJ CJ12
.13 13 13 13 0 lP
l" u r" 0 b g
o e;. "
cc i5 a h o F:u " .fJ 1·( kI e
o ....

11/2 (8
1/2 PART C 6x15=9u
A
Answer each questiun in about 150 words. Each question carnes
o
15 marks.
I

1.
Define and explain the offence of theft.

2.
Discuss the elements required to constitute a tort of defamation.


1
t
r

3. Explain the circumstances under which an agreement can be vitiated on
t
the ground of consent having been given under mistake. Refer to decided
I
cases.
4.
Explain 'Promissory Distinguish it from a 'Cheque' and a 'Bill of Exchange'.

5.
Discuss the rights and duties of the agent towards his principal.

6.
Explain the principle of Vicarious Liability.



o.



N
Q)
a

on" c
fl?-ft tl 0
X
tl 13 lu

-e 13 Vi, fJ B
0E
II f!i
0
II
13 l'jl
0
on Bf.J ." l'jl
n o



S

ljl 0




"" -G
"l ii



iJ lu
fJ lJ iii fJ
II
Q b
b 1P

n 13-h
IIW
" B
"l
12
u

it:"P
Clo"

m b 3
18
lJ
Ii:
5- iJ II
13
0
:to 51:

13
TI q.,
.z .z lu
a ,0
a a ;jJ
fJ 1·Z n
a
on

13 <Cl 0 "
n
"l3 'btl lJ
§ n 13 ., 12
"2
b 13 18 «J.
tl fJ FJ 0
"l1 Ii: o
n ••
0
" S Qb (Ol .., F ...,h'1 to n
<fi3 ..:
Q ,0

1P 0
e
w n
"IC J Q
"l J 13


1P tl .J R

I101
PART D

Answer any three of the following questions, each in about 300 words. Each question carries 30 marks.
1.
'When is an offence of murder considered as culpable homicide not amounting to murder? Explain.

2.
Discuss the scope of duty of care to be taken in the light of the decision in Donoghue V Stevenson. Is this rule extended to repairers also?

3.
Discuss the principles by which damages for breach of contract are determined. Refer to case law.

4.
Explain the scope of the terms 'Deficiency' and 'Consumer' under the Consumers Protection Act.

5.
Define and explain 'Partnership', How is it different from other business entities?


I I1I 11/2


o.)J<)¥,mdtfJJ
100 0.8 30 C'oifT10.
=mri. OlOd;) 21DriffiA:"mt)3D 7


cUliOVrr' V "!.;5ticon tJA)3J
v "...,Q •


T1J,Jl<fO at ""cfudo:t 'IIIi OlOW 21o:irill
. """ 1)J

woW "00 ww'tJmf'l OJtktoCl. 'aotO" al,1i ¢it wowoniJJ.
tJ l..G;l ",.JtJ
120

j
j
j

j
j
j

j
j
j


j
j
j

j
j
j

j
j
j
j